PSI Sci
New here? Follow the money and the votes · Not sure of your district? Find your U.S. House member · Find your state legislators

House roll call 177 (1996): On Agreeing to the Amendment, HCONRES178

Before you vote › House votes

House roll call 177 (1996): On Agreeing to the Amendment, HCONRES178

1996-05-16 · HCONRES178

Follow this vote, step by step

  1. The bill: HCONRES178
  2. What was asked: On Agreeing to the Amendment (this is not always the final vote on the bill)
  3. What happened: Failed on 1996-05-16 · how each member voted
  4. Where the bill stands now: unknown here; check the official record

Question: On Agreeing to the Amendment · (HOUSE REJECTED THE ORTON AMENDMENT, IN THE NATURE OF SUBSTITUTE, THAT SOUGHT TO ACHIEVE A BALANCED BUDGET BY 2002, REDUCE DEFENSE SPENDING, ACHIEVE SAVINGS IN MEDICARE, MEDICAID, WELFARE, AND VARIOUS DISCRETIONARY PROGRAMS, INCREASE FUNDING FOR PROGRAMS INCLUDING EDUCATION AND TRAINING, HEALTH, COMMUNITY DEVELOPMENT, AND RESEARCH, ASSUME A .5 PERCENT CHANGE IN THE CPI INDEX, AND PROVIDE NO TAX REDUCTIONS.)

Result: Failed · Yea 130 · Nay 295 · Present 0 · Not voting 8 (majority 1/2)

By party

PartyYeaNayOther / not voting
Democrat110852
Independent010
Republican202096

How each member voted

MemberStatePartyVote
YOUNG, Donald EdwinAKRYea
BACHUS, Spencer T., IIIALRNay
BEVILL, TomALDYea
BROWDER, John GlenALDYea
CALLAHAN, Herbert Leon (Sonny)ALRNay
CRAMER, Robert E. (Bud), Jr.ALDYea
EVERETT, Robert TerryALRNay
HILLIARD, Earl FrederickALDYea
DICKEY, Jay W., Jr.ARRNay
HUTCHINSON, TimothyARRNay
LINCOLN, Blanche LambertARDYea
THORNTON, Raymond Hoyt (Ray), Jr.ARDNay
HAYWORTH, John D., Jr.AZRNay
KOLBE, James ThomasAZRNay
PASTOR, EdAZDNay
SALMON, Matthew JamesAZRNay
SHADEGG, John B.AZRNay
STUMP, Robert LeeAZRNay
BAKER, William P.CARNay
BECERRA, XavierCADNay
BEILENSON, Anthony CharlesCADYea
BERMAN, Howard LawrenceCADNay
BILBRAY, Brian P.CARNay
BONO, SonnyCARNay
BROWN, George Edward, Jr.CADYea
CALVERT, KenCARNay
CAMPBELL, Thomas J.CARYea
CONDIT, Gary AdrianCADYea
COX, Charles ChristopherCARNay
CUNNINGHAM, Randall (Duke)CARNay
DELLUMS, Ronald V.CADNay
DIXON, Julian CareyCADNay
DOOLEY, Calvin M.CADYea
DOOLITTLE, John TaylorCARNay
DORNAN, Robert KennethCARNay
DREIER, David TimothyCARNay
ESHOO, Anna GeorgesCADYea
FARR, SamCADYea
FAZIO, Victor Herbert, Jr.CADYea
FILNER, BobCADYea
GALLEGLY, Elton W.CARNay
HARMAN, Jane L.CADYea
HERGER, Walter William (Wally)CARNay
HORN, John Stephen (Steve)CARNay
HUNTER, Duncan LeeCARNay
KIM, Jay C.CARNay
LANTOS, Thomas PeterCADYea
LEWIS, Charles Jeremy (Jerry)CARNay
LOFGREN, ZoeCADYea
MARTÍNEZ, Matthew G.CADYea
MATSUI, Robert T.CADYea
MILLENDER-MCDONALD, JuanitaCADYea
MILLER, GeorgeCADNot Voting
MOORHEAD, Carlos JohnCARNay
McKEON, Howard P. (Buck)CARNay
PACKARD, Ronald C.CARNay
PELOSI, NancyCADNay
POMBO, Richard WilliamCARNay
RADANOVICH, George P.CARNay
RIGGS, Frank D.CARNay
ROHRABACHER, DanaCARNay
ROYBAL-ALLARD, LucilleCADNay
ROYCE, Edward RandallCARNay
SEASTRAND, AndreaCARNay
STARK, Fortney Hillman (Pete), Jr.CADNay
THOMAS, William MarshallCARNay
TORRES, Esteban EdwardCADNay
WATERS, MaxineCADNay
WAXMAN, Henry ArnoldCADNay
WOOLSEY, Lynn C.CADNay
ALLARD, A. WayneCORNay
HEFLEY, Joel M.CORNay
McINNIS, ScottCORNay
SCHAEFER, DanielCORNay
SCHROEDER, Patricia ScottCODYea
SKAGGS, David EvansCODYea
DeLAURO, Rosa L.CTDNay
FRANKS, Gary A.CTRNay
GEJDENSON, SamuelCTDNay
JOHNSON, Nancy LeeCTRYea
KENNELLY, Barbara BaileyCTDYea
SHAYS, Christopher H.CTRNay
CASTLE, Michael NewboldDERNay
BILIRAKIS, MichaelFLRNay
BROWN, CorrineFLDYea
CANADY, Charles TerranceFLRNay
DEUTSCH, Peter R.FLDNay
DIAZ-BALART, LincolnFLRNay
FOLEY, Mark A.FLRNay
FOWLER, Tillie KiddFLRNay
GIBBONS, Sam MelvilleFLDYea
GOSS, Porter J.FLRNay
HASTINGS, Alcee LamarFLDYea
JOHNSTON, Harry A., IIFLDYea
MEEK, Carrie P.FLDYea
MICA, John L.FLRNay
MILLER, DanielFLRNot Voting
McCOLLUM, Ira William, Jr. (Bill)FLRNay
PETERSON, Douglas Brian (Pete)FLDYea
ROS-LEHTINEN, IleanaFLRNay
SCARBOROUGH, Charles JosephFLRNay
SHAW, Eugene Clay, Jr.FLRNay
STEARNS, Clifford BundyFLRNay
THURMAN, Karen L.FLDNay
WELDON, David JosephFLRNay
YOUNG, Charles William (Bill)FLRNay
BARR, BobGARNay
BISHOP, Sanford Dixon, Jr.GADYea
CHAMBLISS, SaxbyGARNay
COLLINS, Michael Allen (Mac)GARNay
DEAL, John NathanGARNay
KINGSTON, JackGARNay
LEWIS, John R.GADNay
LINDER, John ElmerGARNay
McKINNEY, Cynthia AnnGADYea
NORWOOD, Charles W., Jr.GARNay
ABERCROMBIE, NeilHIDNay
MINK, Patsy TakemotoHIDNay
GANSKE, GregIARNay
LATHAM, ThomasIARNay
LEACH, James Albert SmithIARYea
LIGHTFOOT, James RossIARNay
NUSSLE, James AllenIARNay
CHENOWETH-HAGE, Helen P.IDRNay
CRAPO, Michael DeanIDRNay
COLLINS, CardissILDNay
COSTELLO, Jerry FrancisILDNay
CRANE, Philip MillerILRNay
DURBIN, Richard JosephILDNay
EVANS, Lane AllenILDNay
EWING, Thomas W.ILRNay
FAWELL, Harris W.ILRNay
FLANAGAN, Michael P.ILRNay
GUTIÉRREZ, Luis V.ILDNay
HASTERT, John DennisILRNay
HYDE, Henry JohnILRNay
JACKSON, Jesse L., Jr.ILDYea
LAHOOD, Ray H.ILRYea
LIPINSKI, William OliverILDNay
MANZULLO, Donald A.ILRNay
PORTER, John EdwardILRYea
POSHARD, GlennILDYea
RUSH, Bobby L.ILDNay
WELLER, Gerald C. (Jerry)ILRNay
YATES, Sidney RichardILDNay
BURTON, Danny LeeINRNay
BUYER, Stephen EarleINRNay
HAMILTON, Lee HerbertINDYea
HOSTETTLER, John NathanINRNay
JACOBS, Andrew, Jr.INDNay
MYERS, John ThomasINRNay
McINTOSH, David MartinINRNay
ROEMER, Timothy JohnINDYea
SOUDER, Mark EdwardINRNay
VISCLOSKY, PeterINDYea
BROWNBACK, Sam DaleKSRNay
MEYERS, JanKSRNay
ROBERTS, Charles Patrick (Pat)KSRNay
TIAHRT, ToddKSRNay
BAESLER, Henry Scott (Scotty)KYDYea
BUNNING, James Paul DavidKYRNay
LEWIS, RonKYRNay
ROGERS, Harold Dallas (Hal)KYRNay
WARD, Michael DelavanKYDYea
WHITFIELD, Wayne Edward (Ed)KYRNay
BAKER, Richard HughLARNay
FIELDS, CleoLADYea
HAYES, James AllisonLARNot Voting
JEFFERSON, William JenningsLADYea
LIVINGSTON, Robert Linlithgow, Jr.LARNay
MCCRERY, James O., IIILARNay
TAUZIN, Wilbert Joseph (Billy)LARYea
BLUTE, Peter I.MARYea
FRANK, BarneyMADNay
KENNEDY, Joseph Patrick, IIMADNay
MARKEY, Edward JohnMADNay
MEEHAN, Martin ThomasMADYea
MOAKLEY, John JosephMADNay
NEAL, Richard EdmundMADNay
OLVER, John WalterMADYea
STUDDS, Gerry EastmanMADYea
TORKILDSEN, Peter GerardMARNay
BARTLETT, Roscoe GardnerMDRNay
CARDIN, Benjamin LouisMDDYea
CUMMINGS, Elijah EugeneMDDNay
EHRLICH, Robert L., Jr.MDRNay
GILCHREST, Wayne ThomasMDRNay
HOYER, Steny HamiltonMDDYea
MORELLA, Constance A.MDRYea
WYNN, Albert RussellMDDYea
BALDACCI, John EliasMEDYea
LONGLEY, JamesMERNay
BARCIA, James A.MIDYea
BONIOR, David EdwardMIDNay
CAMP, David LeeMIRNay
CHRYSLER, DickMIRNay
COLLINS, Barbara-RoseMIDYea
CONYERS, John, Jr.MIDNay
DINGELL, John David, Jr.MIDYea
EHLERS, Vernon JamesMIRNot Voting
HOEKSTRA, PeterMIRNay
KILDEE, Dale EdwardMIDNay
KNOLLENBERG, JosephMIRNay
LEVIN, Sander MartinMIDNay
RIVERS, Lynn NancyMIDYea
SMITH, Nick H.MIRNay
STUPAK, Bart T.MIDNay
UPTON, Frederick StephenMIRNay
GUTKNECHT, Gilbert W.MNRNay
LUTHER, William PaulMNDYea
MINGE, David R.MNDYea
OBERSTAR, James LouisMNDYea
PETERSON, Collin ClarkMNDYea
RAMSTAD, James (Jim)MNRNay
SABO, Martin OlavMNDYea
VENTO, Bruce FrankMNDYea
CLAY, William Lacy, Sr.MODYea
DANNER, Patsy Ann (Pat)MODNay
EMERSON, Norvell William (Bill)MORNay
GEPHARDT, Richard AndrewMODNay
HANCOCK, Melton D. (Mel)MORNay
McCARTHY, KarenMODYea
SKELTON, Isaac Newton, IV (Ike)MODYea
TALENT, James MatthesMORNot Voting
VOLKMER, Harold LeeMODYea
MONTGOMERY, Gillespie V. (Sonny)MSDYea
PARKER, Michael (Mike)MSRNay
TAYLOR, Gary Eugene (Gene)MSDYea
THOMPSON, BennieMSDYea
WICKER, Roger F.MSRNay
WILLIAMS, John PatrickMTDNay
BALLENGER, CassNCRNay
BURR, Richard M.NCRNay
CLAYTON, Eva M.NCDYea
COBLE, HowardNCRNay
FUNDERBURK, DavidNCRNay
HEFNER, Willie Gathrel (Bill)NCDYea
HEINEMAN, FredNCRNay
JONES, Walter Beaman, Jr.NCRNay
MYRICK, SueNCRNay
ROSE, Charles Grandison, IIINCDYea
TAYLOR, Charles HartNCRNay
WATT, Melvin L.NCDYea
POMEROY, Earl Ralph, IIINDDYea
BARRETT, William E.NERYea
BEREUTER, Douglas KentNERYea
CHRISTENSEN, Jon LynnNERNay
BASS, Charles FosterNHRNay
ZELIFF, William H., Jr.NHRNay
ANDREWS, Robert ErnestNJDYea
FRANKS, Robert DouglasNJRNay
FRELINGHUYSEN, Rodney P.NJRNay
LoBIONDO, Frank A.NJRNay
MARTINI, William J.NJRNay
MENENDEZ, RobertNJDNay
PALLONE, Frank, Jr.NJDNay
PAYNE, Donald MilfordNJDYea
ROUKEMA, Margaret ScafatiNJRYea
SAXTON, Hugh JamesNJRNay
SMITH, Christopher HenryNJRNay
TORRICELLI, Robert GuyNJDNay
ZIMMER, RichardNJRNay
RICHARDSON, BillNMDYea
SCHIFF, Steven HarveyNMRNay
SKEEN, Joseph RichardNMRNay
ENSIGN, John EricNVRNay
VUCANOVICH, Barbara FarrellNVRNay
ACKERMAN, Gary LeonardNYDNay
BOEHLERT, Sherwood LouisNYRNay
ENGEL, Eliot LanceNYDNay
FLAKE, Floyd HaroldNYDYea
FORBES, Michael PatrickNYRNay
FRISA, DanNYRNay
GILMAN, Benjamin ArthurNYRNay
HINCHEY, Maurice DunleaNYDNay
HOUGHTON, Amory, Jr.NYRNay
KELLY, Sue W.NYRNay
KING, Peter T.NYRNay
LAZIO, Enrico A. (Rick)NYRNay
LOWEY, Nita M.NYDNay
LaFALCE, John JosephNYDYea
MALONEY, Carolyn BosherNYDNay
MANTON, Thomas J.NYDNay
MOLINARI, SusanNYRNot Voting
McHUGH, John MichaelNYRNay
McNULTY, Michael RobertNYDNay
NADLER, Jerrold LewisNYDNay
OWENS, Major Robert OdellNYDNay
PAXON, L. WilliamNYRNot Voting
QUINN, John Francis (Jack)NYRNay
RANGEL, Charles B.NYDNay
SCHUMER, Charles Ellis (Chuck)NYDNay
SERRANO, José E.NYDNay
SLAUGHTER, Louise McIntoshNYDNay
SOLOMON, Gerald Brooks HuntNYRNay
TOWNS, EdolphusNYDYea
VELÁZQUEZ, Nydia M.NYDNay
WALSH, James T.NYRNay
BOEHNER, John AndrewOHRNay
BROWN, SherrodOHDNay
CHABOT, SteveOHRNay
CREMEANS, FrankOHRNay
GILLMOR, Paul EugeneOHRNay
HALL, Tony PatrickOHDYea
HOBSON, David LeeOHRNay
HOKE, Martin R.OHRNay
KAPTUR, Marcia Carolyn (Marcy)OHDNay
KASICH, John RichardOHRNay
LaTOURETTE, Steven C.OHRNay
NEY, Robert WilliamOHRNay
OXLEY, Michael GarverOHRNay
PORTMAN, Robert Jones (Rob)OHRNay
PRYCE, Deborah D.OHRNay
REGULA, Ralph StrausOHRNay
SAWYER, Thomas CharlesOHDYea
STOKES, LouisOHDYea
TRAFICANT, James A., Jr.OHDNay
BREWSTER, William K.OKDYea
COBURN, Thomas AllenOKRNay
ISTOOK, Ernest James, Jr.OKRNay
LARGENT, SteveOKRNay
LUCAS, Frank D.OKRNay
WATTS, Julius Caesar, Jr. (J. C.)OKRNay
BUNN, JimORRNay
COOLEY, WesORRNay
DeFAZIO, Peter AnthonyORDNay
FURSE, ElizabethORDYea
BORSKI, Robert Anthony, Jr.PADNay
CLINGER, William Floyd, Jr.PARNay
COYNE, William JosephPADNay
DOYLE, Michael F.PADYea
ENGLISH, Philip SheridanPARNay
FATTAH, ChakaPADYea
FOGLIETTA, Thomas MichaelPADYea
FOX, Jon D.PARNay
GEKAS, George WilliamPARNay
GOODLING, William FranklinPARNay
GREENWOOD, James CharlesPARNay
HOLDEN, Thomas Timothy (Tim)PADYea
KANJORSKI, Paul E.PADNay
KLINK, RonaldPADNay
MASCARA, Frank R.PADNay
MCHALE, Paul F., Jr.PADYea
MURTHA, John Patrick, Jr.PADYea
McDADE, Joseph MichaelPARYea
SHUSTER, E. G. (Bud)PARNay
WALKER, Robert SmithPARNay
WELDON, Wayne Curtis (Curt)PARNay
KENNEDY, Patrick JosephRIDNay
REED, John F. (Jack)RIDNay
CLYBURN, James EnosSCDYea
GRAHAM, Lindsey O.SCRNay
INGLIS, Robert DurdenSCRNay
SANFORD, MarkSCRNay
SPENCE, Floyd DavidsonSCRNay
SPRATT, John McKee, Jr.SCDYea
JOHNSON, Timothy Peter (Tim)SDDNay
BRYANT, EdTNRNay
CLEMENT, Robert NelsonTNDYea
DUNCAN, John J., Jr.TNRYea
FORD, Harold EugeneTNDNot Voting
GORDON, Barton JenningsTNDYea
HILLEARY, VanTNRNay
QUILLEN, James HenryTNRNay
TANNER, John S.TNDYea
WAMP, Zachary PaulTNRYea
ARCHER, William Reynolds, Jr.TXRNay
ARMEY, Richard KeithTXRNay
BARTON, Joe LinusTXRYea
BENTSEN, Kenneth E., Jr.TXDYea
BONILLA, HenryTXRNay
BRYANT, John WileyTXDNay
CHAPMAN, JimTXDYea
COLEMAN, Ronald D'EmoryTXDNay
COMBEST, Larry EdTXRNay
DOGGETT, Lloyd Alton, IITXDYea
DeLAY, Thomas DaleTXRNay
EDWARDS, Thomas Chester (Chet)TXDNay
FIELDS, Jack Milton, Jr.TXRNay
FROST, Jonas MartinTXDNay
GEREN, Preston M. (Pete)TXDYea
GONZÁLEZ, Henry B.TXDNay
GREEN, Raymond Eugene (Gene)TXDNay
HALL, Ralph MoodyTXDYea
JACKSON LEE, SheilaTXDYea
JOHNSON, Eddie BerniceTXDYea
JOHNSON, SamTXRNay
LAUGHLIN, Gregory H.TXRNay
ORTIZ, Solomon P.TXDYea
SMITH, Lamar SeeligsonTXRNay
STENHOLM, Charles WalterTXDYea
STOCKMAN, SteveTXRNay
TEJEDA, FrankTXDNay
THORNBERRY, William McClellan (Mac)TXRNay
WILSON, CharlesTXDYea
de la GARZA, Eligio, II (Kika)TXDYea
GREENE WALDHOLTZ, EnidUTRNay
HANSEN, James VearUTRNay
ORTON, WilliamUTDYea
BATEMAN, Herbert HarvellVARNay
BLILEY, Thomas Jerome, Jr.VARNay
BOUCHER, Frederick C.VADNay
DAVIS, Thomas M., IIIVARYea
GOODLATTE, Robert WilliamVARNay
MORAN, James P.VADYea
PAYNE, Lewis Franklin, Jr.VADYea
PICKETT, Owen BradfordVADNay
SCOTT, Robert C.VADYea
SISISKY, NormanVADYea
WOLF, Frank RudolphVARNay
SANDERS, BernardVTINay
DICKS, Norman DeValoisWADYea
DUNN, Jennifer BlackburnWARNay
HASTINGS, Richard Norman (Doc)WARNay
MCDERMOTT, James A.WADYea
METCALF, JackWARYea
NETHERCUTT, George R., Jr.WARNay
SMITH, LindaWARNay
TATE, Randy J.WARNay
WHITE, Richard Alan (Rick)WARNay
BARRETT, Thomas M.WIDYea
GUNDERSON, Steven CraigWIRYea
KLECZKA, Gerald DanielWIDNay
KLUG, Scott L.WIRYea
NEUMANN, Mark W.WIRNay
OBEY, David RossWIDNay
PETRI, Thomas EvertWIRNay
ROTH, Toby A.WIRNay
SENSENBRENNER, Frank James, Jr.WIRNay
MOLLOHAN, Alan BowlbyWVDNay
RAHALL, Nick Joe, IIWVDNay
WISE, Robert Ellsworth, Jr.WVDYea
CUBIN, Barbara L.WYRNay

President's position (not a member vote)

CLINTON, William Jefferson (Bill) (D): Not Voting

Voteview lists the President's announced position on some roll calls (member row with state 'USA'). It is shown separately and is not counted in the totals; it is not a vote cast by a member.

Source: Voteview (UCLA), 104th Congress (roll call file) · official record: Clerk vote page · collected 2026-11-15T05:52:20Z

Record fed-us-house-1996-roll177 · updated 2026-11-15 by psicol votes-house-past