PSI Sci
New here? Follow the money and the votes · Not sure of your district? Find your U.S. House member · Find your state legislators

House roll call 452 (1996): Suspend the rules and pass, HR3163

Before you vote › House votes

House roll call 452 (1996): Suspend the rules and pass, HR3163

1996-09-28 · HR3163

Follow this vote, step by step

  1. The bill: HR3163
  2. What was asked: Suspend the rules and pass (this is not always the final vote on the bill)
  3. What happened: Failed on 1996-09-28 · how each member voted
  4. Where the bill stands now: unknown here; check the official record

Question: Suspend the rules and pass · State Authority Tax Compensation Act

Result: Failed · Yea 199 · Nay 209 · Present 0 · Not voting 25 (majority 2/3)

By party

PartyYeaNayOther / not voting
Democrat917316
Independent010
Republican190359

How each member voted

MemberStatePartyVote
YOUNG, Donald EdwinAKRYea
BACHUS, Spencer T., IIIALRYea
BEVILL, TomALDNay
BROWDER, John GlenALDNay
CALLAHAN, Herbert Leon (Sonny)ALRNay
CRAMER, Robert E. (Bud), Jr.ALDNay
EVERETT, Robert TerryALRNay
HILLIARD, Earl FrederickALDNay
DICKEY, Jay W., Jr.ARRNay
HUTCHINSON, TimothyARRYea
LINCOLN, Blanche LambertARDNot Voting
THORNTON, Raymond Hoyt (Ray), Jr.ARDNay
HAYWORTH, John D., Jr.AZRYea
KOLBE, James ThomasAZRYea
PASTOR, EdAZDNay
SALMON, Matthew JamesAZRNay
SHADEGG, John B.AZRYea
STUMP, Robert LeeAZRNay
BAKER, William P.CARYea
BECERRA, XavierCADNay
BEILENSON, Anthony CharlesCADNay
BERMAN, Howard LawrenceCADNot Voting
BILBRAY, Brian P.CARNay
BONO, SonnyCARYea
BROWN, George Edward, Jr.CADNay
CALVERT, KenCARYea
CAMPBELL, Thomas J.CARNay
CONDIT, Gary AdrianCADNay
COX, Charles ChristopherCARYea
CUNNINGHAM, Randall (Duke)CARYea
DELLUMS, Ronald V.CADNot Voting
DIXON, Julian CareyCADNay
DOOLEY, Calvin M.CADNay
DOOLITTLE, John TaylorCARNot Voting
DORNAN, Robert KennethCARYea
DREIER, David TimothyCARYea
ESHOO, Anna GeorgesCADNay
FARR, SamCADNay
FAZIO, Victor Herbert, Jr.CADNay
FILNER, BobCADNot Voting
GALLEGLY, Elton W.CARYea
HARMAN, Jane L.CADNay
HERGER, Walter William (Wally)CARYea
HORN, John Stephen (Steve)CARYea
HUNTER, Duncan LeeCARYea
KIM, Jay C.CARYea
LANTOS, Thomas PeterCADNay
LEWIS, Charles Jeremy (Jerry)CARYea
LOFGREN, ZoeCADNay
MARTÍNEZ, Matthew G.CADYea
MATSUI, Robert T.CADNay
MILLENDER-MCDONALD, JuanitaCADNay
MILLER, GeorgeCADNay
MOORHEAD, Carlos JohnCARNay
McKEON, Howard P. (Buck)CARYea
PACKARD, Ronald C.CARYea
PELOSI, NancyCADNay
POMBO, Richard WilliamCARYea
RADANOVICH, George P.CARYea
RIGGS, Frank D.CARNay
ROHRABACHER, DanaCARYea
ROYBAL-ALLARD, LucilleCADNay
ROYCE, Edward RandallCARYea
SEASTRAND, AndreaCARYea
STARK, Fortney Hillman (Pete), Jr.CADNay
THOMAS, William MarshallCARNay
TORRES, Esteban EdwardCADNay
WATERS, MaxineCADNot Voting
WAXMAN, Henry ArnoldCADNot Voting
WOOLSEY, Lynn C.CADNay
ALLARD, A. WayneCORYea
HEFLEY, Joel M.CORYea
McINNIS, ScottCORYea
SCHAEFER, DanielCORYea
SCHROEDER, Patricia ScottCODNay
SKAGGS, David EvansCODNay
DeLAURO, Rosa L.CTDNay
FRANKS, Gary A.CTRYea
GEJDENSON, SamuelCTDNay
JOHNSON, Nancy LeeCTRNay
KENNELLY, Barbara BaileyCTDNay
SHAYS, Christopher H.CTRNay
CASTLE, Michael NewboldDERNay
BILIRAKIS, MichaelFLRYea
BROWN, CorrineFLDNay
CANADY, Charles TerranceFLRYea
DEUTSCH, Peter R.FLDNay
DIAZ-BALART, LincolnFLRYea
FOLEY, Mark A.FLRYea
FOWLER, Tillie KiddFLRNot Voting
GIBBONS, Sam MelvilleFLDNay
GOSS, Porter J.FLRYea
HASTINGS, Alcee LamarFLDNay
JOHNSTON, Harry A., IIFLDNay
MEEK, Carrie P.FLDNay
MICA, John L.FLRYea
MILLER, DanielFLRYea
McCOLLUM, Ira William, Jr. (Bill)FLRYea
PETERSON, Douglas Brian (Pete)FLDNay
ROS-LEHTINEN, IleanaFLRYea
SCARBOROUGH, Charles JosephFLRNay
SHAW, Eugene Clay, Jr.FLRYea
STEARNS, Clifford BundyFLRNay
THURMAN, Karen L.FLDNay
WELDON, David JosephFLRYea
YOUNG, Charles William (Bill)FLRYea
BARR, BobGARYea
BISHOP, Sanford Dixon, Jr.GADYea
CHAMBLISS, SaxbyGARNay
COLLINS, Michael Allen (Mac)GARYea
DEAL, John NathanGARYea
KINGSTON, JackGARYea
LEWIS, John R.GADNay
LINDER, John ElmerGARYea
McKINNEY, Cynthia AnnGADNay
NORWOOD, Charles W., Jr.GARYea
ABERCROMBIE, NeilHIDNay
MINK, Patsy TakemotoHIDNay
GANSKE, GregIARYea
LATHAM, ThomasIARYea
LEACH, James Albert SmithIARYea
LIGHTFOOT, James RossIARYea
NUSSLE, James AllenIARYea
CHENOWETH-HAGE, Helen P.IDRNay
CRAPO, Michael DeanIDRYea
COLLINS, CardissILDNay
COSTELLO, Jerry FrancisILDNay
CRANE, Philip MillerILRNay
DURBIN, Richard JosephILDNot Voting
EVANS, Lane AllenILDNay
EWING, Thomas W.ILRYea
FAWELL, Harris W.ILRYea
FLANAGAN, Michael P.ILRYea
GUTIÉRREZ, Luis V.ILDNay
HASTERT, John DennisILRYea
HYDE, Henry JohnILRYea
JACKSON, Jesse L., Jr.ILDNay
LAHOOD, Ray H.ILRYea
LIPINSKI, William OliverILDNay
MANZULLO, Donald A.ILRYea
PORTER, John EdwardILRYea
POSHARD, GlennILDNay
RUSH, Bobby L.ILDNay
WELLER, Gerald C. (Jerry)ILRYea
YATES, Sidney RichardILDNay
BURTON, Danny LeeINRNay
BUYER, Stephen EarleINRYea
HAMILTON, Lee HerbertINDNay
HOSTETTLER, John NathanINRYea
JACOBS, Andrew, Jr.INDNay
MYERS, John ThomasINRNot Voting
McINTOSH, David MartinINRYea
ROEMER, Timothy JohnINDNay
SOUDER, Mark EdwardINRNay
VISCLOSKY, PeterINDNay
BROWNBACK, Sam DaleKSRYea
MEYERS, JanKSRYea
ROBERTS, Charles Patrick (Pat)KSRYea
TIAHRT, ToddKSRYea
BAESLER, Henry Scott (Scotty)KYDNay
BUNNING, James Paul DavidKYRYea
LEWIS, RonKYRYea
ROGERS, Harold Dallas (Hal)KYRYea
WARD, Michael DelavanKYDNay
WHITFIELD, Wayne Edward (Ed)KYRYea
BAKER, Richard HughLARNot Voting
FIELDS, CleoLADNay
HAYES, James AllisonLARNot Voting
JEFFERSON, William JenningsLADNay
LIVINGSTON, Robert Linlithgow, Jr.LARYea
MCCRERY, James O., IIILARYea
TAUZIN, Wilbert Joseph (Billy)LARYea
BLUTE, Peter I.MARYea
FRANK, BarneyMADNot Voting
KENNEDY, Joseph Patrick, IIMADNay
MARKEY, Edward JohnMADNay
MEEHAN, Martin ThomasMADNay
MOAKLEY, John JosephMADNay
NEAL, Richard EdmundMADNay
OLVER, John WalterMADNay
STUDDS, Gerry EastmanMADNay
TORKILDSEN, Peter GerardMARNay
BARTLETT, Roscoe GardnerMDRYea
CARDIN, Benjamin LouisMDDNot Voting
CUMMINGS, Elijah EugeneMDDNay
EHRLICH, Robert L., Jr.MDRYea
GILCHREST, Wayne ThomasMDRYea
HOYER, Steny HamiltonMDDNay
MORELLA, Constance A.MDRYea
WYNN, Albert RussellMDDNay
BALDACCI, John EliasMEDNay
LONGLEY, JamesMERNay
BARCIA, James A.MIDNay
BONIOR, David EdwardMIDNay
CAMP, David LeeMIRYea
CHRYSLER, DickMIRYea
COLLINS, Barbara-RoseMIDNot Voting
CONYERS, John, Jr.MIDNot Voting
DINGELL, John David, Jr.MIDNay
EHLERS, Vernon JamesMIRYea
HOEKSTRA, PeterMIRYea
KILDEE, Dale EdwardMIDNay
KNOLLENBERG, JosephMIRYea
LEVIN, Sander MartinMIDNay
RIVERS, Lynn NancyMIDNay
SMITH, Nick H.MIRNay
STUPAK, Bart T.MIDNay
UPTON, Frederick StephenMIRYea
GUTKNECHT, Gilbert W.MNRNay
LUTHER, William PaulMNDNay
MINGE, David R.MNDNay
OBERSTAR, James LouisMNDNay
PETERSON, Collin ClarkMNDNay
RAMSTAD, James (Jim)MNRNay
SABO, Martin OlavMNDNay
VENTO, Bruce FrankMNDNay
CLAY, William Lacy, Sr.MODNay
DANNER, Patsy Ann (Pat)MODNay
GEPHARDT, Richard AndrewMODNay
HANCOCK, Melton D. (Mel)MORNot Voting
McCARTHY, KarenMODNay
SKELTON, Isaac Newton, IV (Ike)MODNay
TALENT, James MatthesMORYea
VOLKMER, Harold LeeMODNay
MONTGOMERY, Gillespie V. (Sonny)MSDNay
PARKER, Michael (Mike)MSRNay
TAYLOR, Gary Eugene (Gene)MSDNay
THOMPSON, BennieMSDNay
WICKER, Roger F.MSRYea
WILLIAMS, John PatrickMTDNay
BALLENGER, CassNCRYea
BURR, Richard M.NCRNay
CLAYTON, Eva M.NCDNay
COBLE, HowardNCRYea
FUNDERBURK, DavidNCRNay
HEFNER, Willie Gathrel (Bill)NCDNay
HEINEMAN, FredNCRNot Voting
JONES, Walter Beaman, Jr.NCRNay
MYRICK, SueNCRYea
ROSE, Charles Grandison, IIINCDNot Voting
TAYLOR, Charles HartNCRNot Voting
WATT, Melvin L.NCDNay
POMEROY, Earl Ralph, IIINDDNay
BARRETT, William E.NERYea
BEREUTER, Douglas KentNERYea
CHRISTENSEN, Jon LynnNERYea
BASS, Charles FosterNHRYea
ZELIFF, William H., Jr.NHRYea
ANDREWS, Robert ErnestNJDNay
FRANKS, Robert DouglasNJRYea
FRELINGHUYSEN, Rodney P.NJRYea
LoBIONDO, Frank A.NJRYea
MARTINI, William J.NJRYea
MENENDEZ, RobertNJDNot Voting
PALLONE, Frank, Jr.NJDNay
PAYNE, Donald MilfordNJDNay
ROUKEMA, Margaret ScafatiNJRYea
SAXTON, Hugh JamesNJRYea
SMITH, Christopher HenryNJRYea
TORRICELLI, Robert GuyNJDNay
ZIMMER, RichardNJRYea
RICHARDSON, BillNMDNay
SCHIFF, Steven HarveyNMRNay
SKEEN, Joseph RichardNMRNay
ENSIGN, John EricNVRYea
VUCANOVICH, Barbara FarrellNVRYea
ACKERMAN, Gary LeonardNYDNay
BOEHLERT, Sherwood LouisNYRYea
ENGEL, Eliot LanceNYDNay
FLAKE, Floyd HaroldNYDNay
FORBES, Michael PatrickNYRYea
FRISA, DanNYRYea
GILMAN, Benjamin ArthurNYRYea
HINCHEY, Maurice DunleaNYDNay
HOUGHTON, Amory, Jr.NYRYea
KELLY, Sue W.NYRYea
KING, Peter T.NYRYea
LAZIO, Enrico A. (Rick)NYRYea
LOWEY, Nita M.NYDNay
LaFALCE, John JosephNYDNay
MALONEY, Carolyn BosherNYDNay
MANTON, Thomas J.NYDNay
MOLINARI, SusanNYRYea
McHUGH, John MichaelNYRYea
McNULTY, Michael RobertNYDNay
NADLER, Jerrold LewisNYDNay
OWENS, Major Robert OdellNYDNay
PAXON, L. WilliamNYRYea
QUINN, John Francis (Jack)NYRYea
RANGEL, Charles B.NYDNay
SCHUMER, Charles Ellis (Chuck)NYDNay
SERRANO, José E.NYDNay
SLAUGHTER, Louise McIntoshNYDNay
SOLOMON, Gerald Brooks HuntNYRYea
TOWNS, EdolphusNYDNay
VELÁZQUEZ, Nydia M.NYDNay
WALSH, James T.NYRYea
BOEHNER, John AndrewOHRYea
BROWN, SherrodOHDNay
CHABOT, SteveOHRYea
CREMEANS, FrankOHRYea
GILLMOR, Paul EugeneOHRYea
HALL, Tony PatrickOHDNay
HOBSON, David LeeOHRYea
HOKE, Martin R.OHRYea
KAPTUR, Marcia Carolyn (Marcy)OHDNay
KASICH, John RichardOHRYea
LaTOURETTE, Steven C.OHRYea
NEY, Robert WilliamOHRYea
OXLEY, Michael GarverOHRYea
PORTMAN, Robert Jones (Rob)OHRYea
PRYCE, Deborah D.OHRYea
REGULA, Ralph StrausOHRYea
SAWYER, Thomas CharlesOHDNay
STOKES, LouisOHDNay
TRAFICANT, James A., Jr.OHDYea
BREWSTER, William K.OKDYea
COBURN, Thomas AllenOKRYea
ISTOOK, Ernest James, Jr.OKRYea
LARGENT, SteveOKRYea
LUCAS, Frank D.OKRYea
WATTS, Julius Caesar, Jr. (J. C.)OKRYea
BLUMENAUER, EarlORDNot Voting
BUNN, JimORRYea
COOLEY, WesORRNay
DeFAZIO, Peter AnthonyORDNay
FURSE, ElizabethORDNay
BORSKI, Robert Anthony, Jr.PADNay
CLINGER, William Floyd, Jr.PARYea
COYNE, William JosephPADNay
DOYLE, Michael F.PADNay
ENGLISH, Philip SheridanPARYea
FATTAH, ChakaPADNay
FOGLIETTA, Thomas MichaelPADNay
FOX, Jon D.PARYea
GEKAS, George WilliamPARYea
GOODLING, William FranklinPARYea
GREENWOOD, James CharlesPARYea
HOLDEN, Thomas Timothy (Tim)PADNay
KANJORSKI, Paul E.PADNay
KLINK, RonaldPADNay
MASCARA, Frank R.PADNay
MCHALE, Paul F., Jr.PADNay
MURTHA, John Patrick, Jr.PADNay
McDADE, Joseph MichaelPARYea
SHUSTER, E. G. (Bud)PARYea
WALKER, Robert SmithPARYea
WELDON, Wayne Curtis (Curt)PARYea
KENNEDY, Patrick JosephRIDNay
REED, John F. (Jack)RIDNay
CLYBURN, James EnosSCDNay
GRAHAM, Lindsey O.SCRYea
INGLIS, Robert DurdenSCRYea
SANFORD, MarkSCRYea
SPENCE, Floyd DavidsonSCRNay
SPRATT, John McKee, Jr.SCDNay
JOHNSON, Timothy Peter (Tim)SDDNay
BRYANT, EdTNRYea
CLEMENT, Robert NelsonTNDNay
DUNCAN, John J., Jr.TNRYea
FORD, Harold EugeneTNDNay
GORDON, Barton JenningsTNDNay
HILLEARY, VanTNRYea
QUILLEN, James HenryTNRNot Voting
TANNER, John S.TNDNay
WAMP, Zachary PaulTNRYea
ARCHER, William Reynolds, Jr.TXRYea
ARMEY, Richard KeithTXRYea
BARTON, Joe LinusTXRYea
BENTSEN, Kenneth E., Jr.TXDYea
BONILLA, HenryTXRYea
BRYANT, John WileyTXDNay
CHAPMAN, JimTXDNay
COLEMAN, Ronald D'EmoryTXDNay
COMBEST, Larry EdTXRYea
DOGGETT, Lloyd Alton, IITXDNay
DeLAY, Thomas DaleTXRYea
EDWARDS, Thomas Chester (Chet)TXDNay
FIELDS, Jack Milton, Jr.TXRYea
FROST, Jonas MartinTXDNay
GEREN, Preston M. (Pete)TXDNay
GONZÁLEZ, Henry B.TXDNay
GREEN, Raymond Eugene (Gene)TXDNot Voting
HALL, Ralph MoodyTXDYea
JACKSON LEE, SheilaTXDNay
JOHNSON, Eddie BerniceTXDNay
JOHNSON, SamTXRYea
LAUGHLIN, Gregory H.TXRYea
ORTIZ, Solomon P.TXDNay
SMITH, Lamar SeeligsonTXRYea
STENHOLM, Charles WalterTXDNay
STOCKMAN, SteveTXRYea
TEJEDA, FrankTXDNay
THORNBERRY, William McClellan (Mac)TXRYea
WILSON, CharlesTXDNay
de la GARZA, Eligio, II (Kika)TXDNay
GREENE WALDHOLTZ, EnidUTRYea
HANSEN, James VearUTRYea
ORTON, WilliamUTDNay
BATEMAN, Herbert HarvellVARYea
BLILEY, Thomas Jerome, Jr.VARYea
BOUCHER, Frederick C.VADNot Voting
DAVIS, Thomas M., IIIVARYea
GOODLATTE, Robert WilliamVARYea
MORAN, James P.VADNay
PAYNE, Lewis Franklin, Jr.VADNay
PICKETT, Owen BradfordVADNay
SCOTT, Robert C.VADNay
SISISKY, NormanVADYea
WOLF, Frank RudolphVARYea
SANDERS, BernardVTINay
DICKS, Norman DeValoisWADYea
DUNN, Jennifer BlackburnWARYea
HASTINGS, Richard Norman (Doc)WARYea
MCDERMOTT, James A.WADYea
METCALF, JackWARYea
NETHERCUTT, George R., Jr.WARYea
SMITH, LindaWARYea
TATE, Randy J.WARYea
WHITE, Richard Alan (Rick)WARYea
BARRETT, Thomas M.WIDNay
GUNDERSON, Steven CraigWIRYea
KLECZKA, Gerald DanielWIDNay
KLUG, Scott L.WIRNay
NEUMANN, Mark W.WIRYea
OBEY, David RossWIDNay
PETRI, Thomas EvertWIRYea
ROTH, Toby A.WIRYea
SENSENBRENNER, Frank James, Jr.WIRNay
MOLLOHAN, Alan BowlbyWVDNay
RAHALL, Nick Joe, IIWVDNay
WISE, Robert Ellsworth, Jr.WVDNay
CUBIN, Barbara L.WYRYea

President's position (not a member vote)

CLINTON, William Jefferson (Bill) (D): Not Voting

Voteview lists the President's announced position on some roll calls (member row with state 'USA'). It is shown separately and is not counted in the totals; it is not a vote cast by a member.

Source: Voteview (UCLA), 104th Congress (roll call file) · official record: Clerk vote page · collected 2026-11-15T05:52:21Z

Words on this page, explained (1)
Suspension of the rules
A fast way the U.S. House passes measures that have broad support. Debate is limited, no changes are allowed, and it needs a two-thirds vote.

Plain meanings written from linked sources. All words.

Record fed-us-house-1996-roll452 · updated 2026-11-15 by psicol votes-house-past