PSI Sci
New here? Follow the money and the votes · Not sure of your district? Find your U.S. House member · Find your state legislators

House roll call 458 (2008): On Passage, HR2176

Before you vote › House votes

House roll call 458 (2008): On Passage, HR2176

2008-06-25 · H.R. 2176: To provide for and approve the settlement of certain land claims of the Bay Mills Indian Community.

Follow this vote, step by step

  1. The bill: H.R. 2176: To provide for and approve the settlement of certain land claims of the Bay Mills Indian Community. · proposed by Rep. Stupak, Bart [D-MI-1]
  2. What was asked: On Passage (this is not always the final vote on the bill)
  3. What happened: Failed on 2008-06-25 · how each member voted
  4. Where the bill stands now: Motion to reconsider laid on the table Agreed to without objection. Not final yet: this can still change. its other votes

Question: On Passage · To provide for and approve the settlement of certain land claims of the Bay Mills Indian Community

Result: Failed · Yea 121 · Nay 298 · Present 0 · Not voting 15 (majority 1/2)

By party

PartyYeaNayOther / not voting
Democrat961318
Republican251677

How each member voted

MemberStatePartyVote
YOUNG, Donald EdwinAKRYea
ADERHOLT, RobertALRNay
BACHUS, Spencer T., IIIALRNay
BONNER, Jr., Josiah Robins (Jo)ALRNay
CRAMER, Robert E. (Bud), Jr.ALDYea
DAVIS, ArturALDNay
EVERETT, Robert TerryALRNay
ROGERS, Mike DennisALRNay
BERRY, Robert MarionARDYea
BOOZMAN, JohnARRNay
ROSS, Michael AveryARDYea
SNYDER, Victor F.ARDNot Voting
FLAKE, JeffAZRNay
FRANKS, TrentAZRNay
GIFFORDS, GabrielleAZDYea
GRIJALVA, Raúl M.AZDYea
MITCHELL, Harry E.AZDNay
PASTOR, EdAZDYea
RENZI, RickAZRYea
SHADEGG, John B.AZRNay
BACA, JoeCADNay
BECERRA, XavierCADNay
BERMAN, Howard LawrenceCADYea
BILBRAY, Brian P.CARYea
BONO, MaryCARNay
CALVERT, KenCARNay
CAMPBELL, JohnCARNay
CAPPS, LoisCADYea
CARDOZA, Dennis A.CADNay
COSTA, JimCADNay
DAVIS, Susan A.CADNay
DOOLITTLE, John TaylorCARNay
DREIER, David TimothyCARNay
ESHOO, Anna GeorgesCADNay
FARR, SamCADNay
FILNER, BobCADNay
GALLEGLY, Elton W.CARNay
HARMAN, Jane L.CADYea
HERGER, Walter William (Wally)CARNay
HONDA, MikeCADNay
HUNTER, Duncan LeeCARNay
ISSA, DarrellCARNay
LEE, BarbaraCADNay
LEWIS, Charles Jeremy (Jerry)CARNay
LOFGREN, ZoeCADNay
LUNGREN, Daniel EdwardCARYea
MATSUI, DorisCADYea
MCCARTHY, KevinCARNay
MCNERNEY, JerryCADNay
MILLER, Gary G.CARNay
MILLER, GeorgeCADYea
McKEON, Howard P. (Buck)CARYea
NAPOLITANO, Grace FloresCADNay
NUNES, DevinCARNay
RADANOVICH, George P.CARNay
RICHARDSON, LauraCADNay
ROHRABACHER, DanaCARYea
ROYBAL-ALLARD, LucilleCADNay
ROYCE, Edward RandallCARNay
SANCHEZ, LorettaCADNay
SCHIFF, AdamCADNay
SHERMAN, BradCADNay
SOLIS, Hilda L.CADYea
SPEIER, Karen Lorraine Jacqueline (Jackie)CADNot Voting
STARK, Fortney Hillman (Pete), Jr.CADNay
SÁNCHEZ, Linda T.CADNay
TAUSCHER, Ellen O'KaneCADNay
THOMPSON, MichaelCADNay
WATERS, MaxineCADNay
WATSON, Diane EdithCADYea
WAXMAN, Henry ArnoldCADNay
WOOLSEY, Lynn C.CADNay
DEGETTE, DianaCODYea
LAMBORN, DougCORNay
MUSGRAVE, Marilyn NCORNay
PERLMUTTER, EdCODNay
SALAZAR, JohnCODNay
TANCREDO, Thomas G.CORNay
UDALL, MarkCODYea
COURTNEY, JoeCTDNay
DeLAURO, Rosa L.CTDNay
LARSON, John B.CTDNay
MURPHY, ChristopherCTDYea
SHAYS, Christopher H.CTRNay
CASTLE, Michael NewboldDERNay
BILIRAKIS, GusFLRNay
BOYD, F. Allen, Jr.FLDYea
BROWN, CorrineFLDNay
BROWN-WAITE, Virginia (Ginny)FLRNay
BUCHANAN, Vernon G.FLRNay
CASTOR, KathyFLDYea
CRENSHAW, AnderFLRNay
DIAZ-BALART, LincolnFLRYea
DIAZ-BALART, MarioFLRYea
FEENEY, TomFLRNay
HASTINGS, Alcee LamarFLDYea
KELLER, Richard (Ric)FLRNay
KLEIN, RonFLDNay
MACK, Connie, IVFLRNay
MAHONEY, TimFLDNot Voting
MEEK, Kendrick B.FLDNay
MICA, John L.FLRNay
MILLER, Jefferson B. (Jeff)FLRNay
PUTNAM, AdamFLRNot Voting
ROS-LEHTINEN, IleanaFLRNot Voting
STEARNS, Clifford BundyFLRNay
WASSERMAN SCHULTZ, DebbieFLDYea
WELDON, David JosephFLRNay
WEXLER, RobertFLDNay
YOUNG, Charles William (Bill)FLRNay
BARROW, JohnGADYea
BISHOP, Sanford Dixon, Jr.GADNay
BROUN, Paul C., Jr.GARNay
DEAL, John NathanGARNay
GINGREY, PhilGARNay
JOHNSON, HankGADNay
KINGSTON, JackGARNay
LEWIS, John R.GADNay
LINDER, John ElmerGARNay
MARSHALL, JimGADNay
PRICE, TomGARNay
SCOTT, DavidGADNay
WESTMORELAND, Lynn A.GARNay
ABERCROMBIE, NeilHIDYea
HIRONO, MazieHIDYea
BOSWELL, Leonard L.IADYea
BRALEY, BruceIADYea
KING, SteveIARNay
LATHAM, ThomasIARNay
LOEBSACK, DaveIADYea
SALI, WilliamIDRNay
SIMPSON, Michael K.IDRNay
BEAN, Melissa L.ILDYea
BIGGERT, Judy BorgILRNay
COSTELLO, Jerry FrancisILDNay
DAVIS, Danny K.ILDNay
EMANUEL, RahmILDNay
FOSTER, BillILDYea
GUTIÉRREZ, Luis V.ILDNay
HARE, PhilILDNay
JACKSON, Jesse L., Jr.ILDYea
JOHNSON, Timothy V.ILRNay
KIRK, Mark StevenILRNay
LAHOOD, Ray H.ILRNay
LIPINSKI, DanielILDYea
MANZULLO, Donald A.ILRNay
ROSKAM, PeterILRNay
RUSH, Bobby L.ILDNot Voting
SCHAKOWSKY, Janice D.ILDYea
SHIMKUS, John M.ILRNay
WELLER, Gerald C. (Jerry)ILRNay
BURTON, Danny LeeINRNay
BUYER, Stephen EarleINRNay
CARSON, AndréINDNay
DONNELLY, JoeINDNay
ELLSWORTH, BradINDYea
HILL, Baron P.INDYea
PENCE, MikeINRNay
SOUDER, Mark EdwardINRNay
VISCLOSKY, PeterINDNay
BOYDA, NancyKSDNay
MOORE, DennisKSDYea
MORAN, JerryKSRNay
TIAHRT, ToddKSRNay
CHANDLER, A. B. (Ben)KYDNay
DAVIS, Geoffrey C. (Geoff)KYRNay
LEWIS, RonKYRNay
ROGERS, Harold Dallas (Hal)KYRNay
WHITFIELD, Wayne Edward (Ed)KYRNay
YARMUTH, JohnKYDNay
ALEXANDER, RodneyLARNay
BOUSTANY, Charles W.LARNay
CAZAYOUX, Donald J., Jr.LADNay
JEFFERSON, William JenningsLADNay
MCCRERY, James O., IIILARYea
MELANCON, Charles J.LADYea
SCALISE, SteveLARNay
CAPUANO, Michael EverettMADYea
DELAHUNT, BillMADNot Voting
FRANK, BarneyMADYea
LYNCH, Stephen F.MADYea
MARKEY, Edward JohnMADNay
McGOVERN, James P.MADNay
NEAL, Richard EdmundMADNay
OLVER, John WalterMADYea
TIERNEY, John F.MADYea
TSONGAS, Nicola S. (Niki)MADNay
BARTLETT, Roscoe GardnerMDRNay
CUMMINGS, Elijah EugeneMDDNot Voting
EDWARDS, Donna F.MDDNay
GILCHREST, Wayne ThomasMDRYea
HOYER, Steny HamiltonMDDNay
RUPPERSBERGER, C. A. DutchMDDNay
SARBANES, JohnMDDNay
VAN HOLLEN, ChristopherMDDNay
ALLEN, Thomas H.MEDYea
MICHAUD, Michael H.MEDYea
CAMP, David LeeMIRNay
CONYERS, John, Jr.MIDNay
DINGELL, John David, Jr.MIDYea
EHLERS, Vernon JamesMIRNay
HOEKSTRA, PeterMIRNay
KILDEE, Dale EdwardMIDYea
KILPATRICK, Carolyn CheeksMIDNay
KNOLLENBERG, JosephMIRNay
LEVIN, Sander MartinMIDYea
MILLER, Candice S.MIRYea
McCOTTER, Thaddeus GeorgeMIRNot Voting
ROGERS, MikeMIRNay
STUPAK, Bart T.MIDYea
UPTON, Frederick StephenMIRNay
WALBERG, TimMIRNay
BACHMANN, MicheleMNRNay
ELLISON, KeithMNDNay
KLINE, JohnMNRNay
MCCOLLUM, BettyMNDNay
OBERSTAR, James LouisMNDNay
PETERSON, Collin ClarkMNDNay
RAMSTAD, James (Jim)MNRNay
WALZ, TimMNDNay
AKIN, W. ToddMORNay
BLUNT, RoyMORNay
CARNAHAN, RussMODNay
CLAY, William Lacy, Jr.MODYea
CLEAVER, Emanuel, IIMODNay
EMERSON, Jo AnnMORNay
GRAVES, SamuelMORNay
HULSHOF, KennyMORNay
SKELTON, Isaac Newton, IV (Ike)MODNay
CHILDERS, Travis W.MSDNay
PICKERING, Charles W. (Chip), Jr.MSRNay
TAYLOR, Gary Eugene (Gene)MSDNay
THOMPSON, BennieMSDNay
REHBERG, DennyMTRNay
BUTTERFIELD, George Kenneth, Jr. (G.K.)NCDYea
COBLE, HowardNCRNay
ETHERIDGE, Bobby R.NCDNay
FOXX, Virginia AnnNCRNay
HAYES, Robert Cannon (Robin)NCRNay
JONES, Walter Beaman, Jr.NCRNay
MILLER, BradNCDNay
MYRICK, SueNCRNay
McHENRY, Patrick T.NCRNay
McINTYRE, MikeNCDNay
PRICE, David EugeneNCDYea
SHULER, HeathNCDNay
WATT, Melvin L.NCDNay
POMEROY, Earl Ralph, IIINDDYea
FORTENBERRY, JeffNERNay
SMITH, AdrianNERNay
TERRY, Lee RaymondNERNay
HODES, PaulNHDYea
SHEA-PORTER, CarolNHDNay
ANDREWS, Robert ErnestNJDYea
FERGUSON, MichaelNJRNay
FRELINGHUYSEN, Rodney P.NJRNay
GARRETT, ScottNJRNay
HOLT, RushNJDYea
LoBIONDO, Frank A.NJRNay
PALLONE, Frank, Jr.NJDYea
PASCRELL, William J., Jr.NJDNay
PAYNE, Donald MilfordNJDNay
ROTHMAN, StevenNJDYea
SAXTON, Hugh JamesNJRNay
SIRES, AlbioNJDYea
SMITH, Christopher HenryNJRNay
PEARCE, StevanNMRNay
UDALL, Thomas (Tom)NMDNay
WILSON, HeatherNMRNay
BERKLEY, ShelleyNVDNay
HELLER, DeanNVRNay
PORTER, Jon C.NVRNay
ACKERMAN, Gary LeonardNYDNay
ARCURI, MichaelNYDYea
BISHOP, Timothy H.NYDNay
CLARKE, Yvette DianeNYDNay
CROWLEY, JosephNYDNay
ENGEL, Eliot LanceNYDYea
FOSSELLA, Vito JohnNYRNot Voting
GILLIBRAND, KirstenNYDYea
HALL, JohnNYDNay
HIGGINS, BrianNYDYea
HINCHEY, Maurice DunleaNYDNay
ISRAEL, SteveNYDNay
KING, Peter T.NYRYea
KUHL, John R. (Randy), Jr.NYRYea
LOWEY, Nita M.NYDYea
MALONEY, Carolyn BosherNYDYea
MCCARTHY, CarolynNYDNay
MEEKS, Gregory W.NYDNay
McHUGH, John MichaelNYRYea
McNULTY, Michael RobertNYDYea
NADLER, Jerrold LewisNYDNay
RANGEL, Charles B.NYDYea
REYNOLDS, Thomas M.NYRYea
SERRANO, José E.NYDYea
SLAUGHTER, Louise McIntoshNYDNay
TOWNS, EdolphusNYDYea
VELÁZQUEZ, Nydia M.NYDYea
WALSH, James T.NYRYea
WEINER, Anthony D.NYDNay
BOEHNER, John AndrewOHRNay
CHABOT, SteveOHRNay
HOBSON, David LeeOHRNay
JONES, Stephanie TubbsOHDNay
JORDAN, JimOHRNay
KAPTUR, Marcia Carolyn (Marcy)OHDNay
KUCINICH, DennisOHDNay
LATTA, Robert E.OHRNay
LaTOURETTE, Steven C.OHRYea
PRYCE, Deborah D.OHRNay
REGULA, Ralph StrausOHRNay
RYAN, Timothy J.OHDNay
SCHMIDT, JeanOHRNay
SPACE, ZackOHDYea
SUTTON, BettyOHDNot Voting
TIBERI, Patrick (Pat)OHRNay
TURNER, Michael R.OHRNay
WILSON, CharlieOHDYea
BOREN, Daniel DavidOKDNay
COLE, TomOKRYea
FALLIN, MaryOKRNay
LUCAS, Frank D.OKRNay
SULLIVAN, JohnOKRNay
BLUMENAUER, EarlORDYea
DeFAZIO, Peter AnthonyORDNay
HOOLEY, DarleneORDNay
WALDEN, GregORRNay
WU, DavidORDYea
ALTMIRE, JasonPADNay
BRADY, Robert A.PADYea
CARNEY, ChrisPADYea
DENT, Charles W.PARNay
DOYLE, Michael F.PADYea
ENGLISH, Philip SheridanPARYea
FATTAH, ChakaPADNay
GERLACH, JimPARNay
HOLDEN, Thomas Timothy (Tim)PADYea
KANJORSKI, Paul E.PADYea
MURPHY, PatrickPADYea
MURPHY, TimothyPARNay
MURTHA, John Patrick, Jr.PADNay
PETERSON, JohnPARNot Voting
PITTS, Joseph R.PARNay
PLATTS, ToddPARNay
SCHWARTZ, Allyson Y.PADNay
SESTAK, JoePADNay
SHUSTER, William (Bill)PARNay
KENNEDY, Patrick JosephRIDYea
LANGEVIN, JamesRIDNay
BARRETT, James GreshamSCRNay
BROWN, Henry Edward, Jr.SCRNay
CLYBURN, James EnosSCDYea
INGLIS, Robert DurdenSCRNay
SPRATT, John McKee, Jr.SCDNay
WILSON, JoeSCRNay
HERSETH SANDLIN, StephanieSDDYea
BLACKBURN, MarshaTNRNay
COHEN, StephenTNDNay
COOPER, James Hayes ShofnerTNDNay
DAVIS, DavidTNRNay
DAVIS, LincolnTNDNay
DUNCAN, John J., Jr.TNRNay
GORDON, Barton JenningsTNDYea
TANNER, John S.TNDYea
WAMP, Zachary PaulTNRNay
BARTON, Joe LinusTXRYea
BRADY, Kevin PatrickTXRNay
BURGESS, Michael C.TXRNay
CARTER, John R.TXRNay
CONAWAY, K. MichaelTXRNay
CUELLAR, HenryTXDNay
CULBERSON, JohnTXRNay
DOGGETT, Lloyd Alton, IITXDNay
EDWARDS, Thomas Chester (Chet)TXDNay
GOHMERT, LouieTXRNay
GONZALEZ, Charles A.TXDYea
GRANGER, KayTXRNay
GREEN, AlTXDNay
GREEN, Raymond Eugene (Gene)TXDYea
HALL, Ralph MoodyTXRYea
HENSARLING, JebTXRNay
HINOJOSA, RubénTXDNay
JACKSON LEE, SheilaTXDNay
JOHNSON, Eddie BerniceTXDNay
JOHNSON, SamTXRNay
LAMPSON, Nicholas V.TXDNot Voting
MARCHANT, KennyTXRNay
MCCAUL, Michael T.TXRNay
NEUGEBAUER, RandyTXRNay
ORTIZ, Solomon P.TXDYea
PAUL, Ronald ErnestTXRYea
POE, TedTXRNay
REYES, SilvestreTXDYea
RODRIGUEZ, Ciro D.TXDYea
SESSIONS, PeteTXRNay
SMITH, Lamar SeeligsonTXRNay
THORNBERRY, William McClellan (Mac)TXRNay
BISHOP, Robert (Rob)UTRYea
CANNON, Christopher B.UTRNot Voting
MATHESON, James David (Jim)UTDNay
BOUCHER, Frederick C.VADYea
CANTOR, EricVARNay
DAVIS, Thomas M., IIIVARYea
DRAKE, Thelma D.VARNay
FORBES, J. RandyVARNay
GOODE, Virgil H., Jr.VARNay
GOODLATTE, Robert WilliamVARNay
MORAN, James P.VADNay
SCOTT, Robert C.VADNay
WITTMAN, Robert J.VARNay
WOLF, Frank RudolphVARNay
WELCH, PeterVTDYea
BAIRD, BrianWADNay
DICKS, Norman DeValoisWADNay
HASTINGS, Richard Norman (Doc)WARNay
INSLEE, Jay RobertWADYea
LARSEN, Richard Ray (Rick)WADNay
MCDERMOTT, James A.WADNay
MCMORRIS RODGERS, CathyWARNay
REICHERT, David G.WARYea
SMITH, AdamWADYea
BALDWIN, TammyWIDYea
KAGEN, StevenWIDYea
KIND, RonWIDYea
MOORE, Gwendolynne S. (Gwen)WIDNay
OBEY, David RossWIDNay
PETRI, Thomas EvertWIRNay
RYAN, Paul D.WIRNay
SENSENBRENNER, Frank James, Jr.WIRNay
CAPITO, Shelley MooreWVRNay
MOLLOHAN, Alan BowlbyWVDYea
RAHALL, Nick Joe, IIWVDYea
CUBIN, Barbara L.WYRNot Voting

President's position (not a member vote)

BUSH, George Walker (R): Not Voting

Voteview lists the President's announced position on some roll calls (member row with state 'USA'). It is shown separately and is not counted in the totals; it is not a vote cast by a member.

Source: Voteview (UCLA), 110th Congress (roll call file) · official record: Clerk vote page · collected 2026-11-15T05:51:28Z

Record fed-us-house-2008-roll458 · updated 2026-11-15 by psicol votes-house-past